How Old Is Old Enough for Your Child to Stay Home Alone?

I have recently started to let my 10-year-old son stay home alone for short periods of time—no more than an hour or so—and am looking ahead to when I won't need to hire a sitter or ask friends to babysit for me. I know he's not old enough to care for his younger brother yet, but how will I know when he's ready to stay home alone and babysit?
Is there a "magic age" where the responsibility gene kicks in and he will be ready to stay home alone and babysit? On Michael’s thirteenth birthday, will he wake up and be a responsible, trustworthy boy? Am I supposed to be waiting for a time when they don't fight anymore or another telltale sign? Will that ever happen? (It never happened for my brother and I. We fought until I left the house and joined the military.)
Am I supposed to be teaching Michael a special set of babysitting skills that will turn him into a responsible babysitter? He wants to watch his little brother and stay home alone; he’s told us that before. I just don’t think that he’s ready yet.
So, the basics: Michael knows CPR. He understands what constitutes an emergency, and knows when to dial 911. He is responsible enough to remember to feed his little brother (which, by the way, is something I sometimes forgot to do as a new mom) and I have no doubt that he can keep him entertained for a few hours if they were to stay home alone. He is a responsible kid.
Michael is not, however, responsible enough to babysit his little brother. I think that the "big brother" complex would get in the way. I think he would tell Jack to do something and add a little "because I am in charge" at the end. That would, in turn, result in a wrestling match in my living room, making it necessary for Michael to prove that he knows what constitutes an emergency call to 911. Do you see my dilemma?
So tell me. Please!
How old were your kids when you trusted them to stay home alone together? Did it work out for you, or did you have to wait a bit before attempting dinner alone again? I guess there are more questions than answers in my head at this point, and it would be comforting to know I'm not alone in this. Let’s discuss.
Leave a Comment
Leave a Comment
Follow Us
More from iVillage
Our Experts
-
Becca Ludlum
Becca Ludlum was born and raised in upstate New York and currently lives in Arizona with her sons...
-
Melissa Chapman
Melissa Chapman blogs about her marriage and everything in between at marriedmysugardaddy.com, and...
-
Sherry Davey
Sherry Davey is a mom and professional comedian and writer. She has two daughters aged 8 & 14...









I just started leaving my kids home alone last week. My oldest daughter is 11 and incredibly responsible. She completed our city's babysitting course and I trust her being alone, with her sisters and with other children. My other two kids are 8 and 6 and my guess is that they will never be old enough to be left home alone. I think it depends on the maturity of the child. Some kids do much better than others. I know 16 year olds that should never be allowed to stay at home alone.
Unfortunately I was never able to leave my older daughter home to sit with her younger brother. As a matter of fact parents of my babysitters would call and tell me that their teenage girl could no longer babysit for my children. But my daughter grew up to be a most responsible adult with two very well behaved children. I personally think it is ok for the older child to be by himself for short periods, but 10 is too young to have the responsibility of a younger brother or sister. Maybe another year or two and also some childcare classes might help out. And even then it might be good to know for sure a responsible neighbor is close by just in case.
I think he is old enough. I think that even though we have all heard that myth about "because I'm older than you" and I do not believe it.
I have left my ten year old home while I went for a run. He is responsible but I would not put him in charge of anyone else. I have given him eorders to not let the dogs out to go to the bathroom while I am gone. A few years ago he stayed at a friends house overnight, very unusual for us, only to find out that the next morning the mom left them alone to run errands. I was furious! When I asked if she would have left her son home alone she said no but felt that my son could watch him. WAy too young to have that responsibility. What if something happened? He would have that hanging over him forever.
I let my 13 year old niece babysit my 7 year old but on the flip side I would NEVER leave him alone with my 15 year old nephew. It just depends on the maturity of the child and if you FEEL he is ready. My friend has a 12 year old and she watches her little brothers 9 and 6 for 2 hours everday. When I was 12 I was home alone and would have to take care of my 15 year old bro. So like I said it depends on how you feel and if you KNOW in you heart he can handle the responsability. Hopes this helps. ( most states there is a legal age where kids can be left alone, I live in PA so the age is 12, be careful)
My kids were 8 and 11 when we starting letting them ride the bus home from school and be alone for 45 minutes to an hour until one of us got home. BUT the 8 year old was recovering from Mono and came home, ate a granola bar and slept for over an hour. That's why we did it. She couldn't handle the craziness of the after school program. That summer, she was sleeping 2-3 hours in the afternoon, so we rearranged our schedules so they were home alone for 2 hours each day, although I was a 5 minute drive away and DID have to come home a couple of times.
I started babysitting my younger sisters around age 10, they were ages 8 and 5. Sometimes my mom worked early and we had to get ready for school togehter in the morning. Other days my mom worked late and we were home for about 2 hours after school alone. I was very responsible for my age and we never had any problems. Every child is different though. My youngest sister is now 17 and my parents are still hesitant to let her stay home alone for long periods of time.
My oldest daughter was about 11 when she would watch her three younger siblings while I grocery shopped. At 13 she would watch them after school for a couple of hours. She was extremely responsible and the younger ones understood she was in charge. (no one was allowed out of the house while we were gone!!)
On the flip side, my second child is 15.5 years old and I just now started letting her watch the younger two. She just did not have the same high sense of responsiblity that my oldest daughter did.
My son is 11 and my youngest daughter is 9. She is more responsible than her brother, by far.
You have to base staying home alone or with siblings on the individual child and not just the age.
10 years old is just too young! Especially for boys! You must be nuts....
My kids were in 2nd and 5th when they started staying home afterschool alone for a few hours (9th and 6th now). I was nervous at first thinking my son (who is older) would do the "because I'm in charge" and be mean to his little sister. But surprisingly, they get along better for the most part when we are not there. My son really surprised me at how well he watches out for his sister, and will bandage and kiss a booboo. He is very protective of her. It boils down to you know your children (how old is the baby?) If my daughter were in Pre K or younger I probably wouldn't allow a 10 yr old to watch her. I would say if the younger is old enough to "fend for himself" fix a bowl of cereal, use the bathroom without help and can follow simple instructions it might be ok. Try some practice runs with them in the house and you outside working in the yard and see what happens. Then try little short trips to the store and gradually increase your away time.
It's funny. Just about the time you try to figure out how old they can be to leave them alone-- then they go and get old enough when you REALLY don't want to leave them home alone!
I am struggling with this as well. I have a 10 and 8 year old. I have considered leaving them alone for short periods of time. Maybe while I am at the gym for example. The 10 year old is very responsible but I am not sure I should leave her in charge of the 8 year old. I know times have changed, but I was home alone for hours 3-5 during the work week from the time I was in second grade. The kids have phones, neighbors, dogs....my guts just tells me to wait.
It depends on the laws for your state. In Ohio, children under the age of 12 are NOT allowed to be left unsupervised, without an adult, no matter what. And if you have two kids, one 13 and the other 10, then the 13 year old can be left alone, but CANNOT be left in charge of the younger child.
Case in point, a neighbor of mine ran to the store, leaving her eleven year old daughter alone for less than an hour. Her daughter was supposed to stay in the house, but decided to ride her bike in the driveway instead. Of course, she fell off and injured herself and another neighbor called 911. The mom was charged with child abandonment or something similar (she won't really discuss it since it's part of an ongoing custody case the ex-husband brought against her for unlawfully leaving their daughter unsupervised) and is now in danger of losing custody of the girl.
Find out what your state laws are before you even THINK of leaving your children home alone.
It depends on the laws for your state. In Ohio, children under the age of 12 are NOT allowed to be left unsupervised, without an adult, no matter what. And if you have two kids, one 13 and the other 10, then the 13 year old can be left alone, but CANNOT be left in charge of the younger child.
Case in point, a neighbor of mine ran to the store, leaving her eleven year old daughter alone for less than an hour. Her daughter was supposed to stay in the house, but decided to ride her bike in the driveway instead. Of course, she fell off and injured herself and another neighbor called 911. The mom was charged with child abandonment or something similar (she won't really discuss it since it's part of an ongoing custody case the ex-husband brought against her for unlawfully leaving their daughter unsupervised) and is now in danger of losing custody of the girl.
Find out what your state laws are before you even THINK of leaving your children home alone.
Recently my 9 year old daughter had to come home from her also 9 year old friends house because her friends parents had to go shopping/dinner. They left their 9 year old daughter in charge of a 5, 3 and 1.5 year old. I about died when I learned of this. I too have a 6 year old and 1.5 year old. It got me to thinking about what age is appropriate for older siblings to watch over younger siblings? When do we start teaching our kids to be independent and responsible? I personally think 9 is too young for anything longer than a quick run to the store. I think 12 is a good age. From 9-12 a quick errand is a good start but if you plan to be gone longer than 5-10 mins keep using a sitter. I only feel this way because if something were to happen to one of the younger kids or even the one sitting regardless of how responsible they are you would never be able to forgive yourself. There was a recent news story about a mom who had just left the house to run an errand and minutes later the house was being robbed and the robbers were unaware that the 13 year old daughter was home from school sick. I know these situations are rare but there is always a "what if" situation that can happen. But then we come back to when do we start teaching responsibility and independence. Ive taken care of myself since I was 5 years old my parents were always home but they were high on drugs or sleeping it off. I'm a wonderful mom today and I want to teach my kids to be independent and be responsible like I was but in a safe and monitored environment.
I have all girls and I would say that I began leaving them alone around ages 12, 8, and 5. They are now 15, 11, and 8 and I feel completely ok with the situation as the middle child is the most responsible and is usually given all the instructions, while the oldest is there simply for legal issues.
Our daughter went to Lancaster Country Day. In fifth grade the headmaster accused us being latch key parents. She also was a bored student and we had to have her tested. The results of the tests were that she was bored because the school was beneath her abilities. Upon receiving the report we never heard any other mention of these subjects. The school did not do anything that was recommended by the testers. Also in 7th grade she scored 960 on the SAT and became a participant in Duke's TIP program.
It isnt the AGE of the child its the responsibility of the child. My 18 year old daughter is adorable but kinda a unicorn, rainbow, glitter personality on life. My son age 12 is head strong, informative, organized and very intuitive. My daughter was 11 and my son 5 the first time I left them home alone to make a quick run to the town grocery store for milk and bread. Then I took my son with me and left my daughter home alone. Engaged with house rules, chore list and cell phone and notified elderly neighbors across the street who were the step in grandparents. My son he was left home alone the first time after school at the age of 8. I had an unplanned emergency meeting and their dad doesnt get off work until 6. So, his first time home alone he locked the door, armed himself with a cell phone and friendly neighbors across the street. He did WONDERFUL for the 1 1/2 he was by himself. He asked when can we do this again. So, I started doing it in short increments of time then increasing the time. The kids have always done good. I feel its good for them. It shows an age of maturity and a part of responsibility. They know that if they are home alone there is house rules to follow and chores to be done. I am very proud of my children. It also gives them a growth of inner strength to know they are trusted and they can succeed. Cutting the apron strings a tiny bit at a time !
I am a grandmother of a 13 yr old and an 8 yr old...summer is tough for parents with kids this age.. I live close by so they stay home in the mornings and I got and get them for a few hours to do something fun... make sure they have a good lunch and then their parents come to get them.. I however do this only a couple days a week.. the younger one goes to a school program two days a week and the 13 yr old stays home alone.. with me close by if he needs anything..I really think it is alot of responsibility for an older child and this may take from his or her summer of fun too as a kid. Try to give the older kids some time to be a kid too when they "Have to watch" thier siblings.. and of course a good back up close by in case.. They all grow up so fast... enjoy the childhood time...
I realize as a parent you feel the decision on when to leave your children home alone is up to you. HOWEVER, please check with your local laws and state statutes. You'd be surprised that for many states the legal age is between 12-16. If anything were to happen to your home or your child and he/she were under the legal age, the parents can be criminally prosecuted for leaving them home without an adult. So, even though you teach them CPR, how to call 911, and never to answer the door or phone to strangers, they should not be left alone if your state or local laws have indicated a certain age to do so. :)
Most local YMCAs have babysitting courses that teach kids the basics, like how to change diapers, how to prepare bottles, babysitting etiquette, etc. Outside of preparing your kids the skillset of caregiving, you may want to look at your local laws concerning children left alone, so you don't get in trouble with protective services.
Most local YMCAs have babysitting courses for kids of jr. highschool age, and most local laws outline the specifics as to what age a child needs to be before being left home alone.
I don't agree with most of you parents out there. Yes, I do think that there are alot of kids that are mature beyond their years. (Both of my nephews were always mature for their ages). But to leave an eleven year old with a six and eight year old and let a thirteen year old babysit a seven year old is too risky. These kids may be "mature", but they are still kids and will think like kids, not adults.
We left our 2 daughters alone for the first time at 11 & 10 years old. Someone came and knocked on the door and they freaked out and called me. They ended up hiding in the closet until I could get home. So, we decided to wait a while longer and have just started letting them stay home alone again at the age of 13 & 12. Never at night and just for several hours during the day. Its a hard choice to know when they are ready, but it was also very terrifying for me to be on the phone with them while they were freaking out and hiding, knowing that I was 20 minutes away. I guess it depends on the childs maturity and what you feel comfortable with.
I just looked up the OHIO laws on ages that is illegal to leave kids alone....Says no minimum age. I have 4 daughters 21,17,10,13 all girls. Typically girls are more mature, but with that said, my 21 yr old was more mature at 10 than my 17 yr old was at 14. You know your kids.
http://www.latchkey-kids.com/latchkey-kids-age-limits.htm
This is the legal aspect of leaving kids alone.
my twelve year old grandson has been told by his working parents that he is in charge when they are at my house until parents come home ! The twelve year old is constantly yelling and bossing the younger ones around and he argues with me over any issue that he thinks differently than I.When the two younger ones are with me , there are some small issues but nothing that causes stress, tension, yelling and bossing like there is when the twelve year old is on the scene. This scenario has now escalated to a point where I ( the Grand Parent) can not stand the twelve year old antics when his parents are not around. And the twelve year old is smart enough to pit me against the parents. The parents leave the kids un- supervised when they are at home and excuse what I would call miss-behavior as ( oh, there are just kids. ) My 61 year old senses are are screaming to be any where but within ear or eye shot of this. And if i am not heavily medicated my fuse can not be long enough before I say something to the twelve year old, and at that point I may be hugely stressed for a moment or two . What then may happen is a shouting, yelling, arguing to shut the twelve year old up, as he is in charge and what he says goes. i am going crazy, I try and try with this twelve year old but he is challenged on a focus level. Do not Know what to do, other than taking my self totally out of the picture, a picture of 38 years with my wife and the home and property i love.
8
I don't agree with most of you parents out there. Yes, I do think that there are alot of kids that are mature beyond their years. (Both of my nephews were always mature for their ages). But to leave an eleven year old with a six and eight year old and let a thirteen year old babysit a seven year old is too risky. These kids may be "mature", but they are still kids and will think like kids, not adults.
http://www.atcoachoutletonline.net/
Most of the parents normally leave their children at home alone at the age of 12 and above. But maturity of a child doesn't only depend on her/his age. They should be mature enough to handle unexpected situations. I am very comfortable leaving my children at home alone because I know that they are well-educated on what to do in case of emergency. Besides, I did register them also to SafeKidZone. It is a panic button installed on their phones that in just a press of it , it will simultaneously alert their trusted friends, family members and the nearest 911 with complete information. If you want to chck out, this is their site http://Safekidzone.com/