Man Up: Should Boys Be Allowed to Cry?

Should we put a stigma on our sons if they cry? Or should they be allowed to express their emotions freely?
by Dionne Grayman on January 09, 2012

My son's football team traveled to Tampa to play gridiron gladiators for a week. They pounded and were pounded on in equal measures and he returned home happy, tired, and unharmed. On his first day back to school, I received a call from the school nurse informing me that I needed to get to the school as quickly as possible because she thought he had broken his hand.

The first thing I saw upon entering her office was his hand which was swollen to the size of a canned ham.

" What happened?"

"I was playing basketball and tripped over a football."

Of course.  As I was helping him get his jacket on, he winced and let out a yelp. Some-random-male-school-employee who was in the nurse's office offered a hale, hearty "Man up!" Did I mention his hand was the size of a canned ham, six different colors and visibly throbbing?

Once in the X-ray room, while the tech was positioning it on the plate, he winced and let out a yelp. And, again, some-random-male-hospital employee suggested he "Man up". I'm not sure at what point in the "He Man Alpha Male manual" actual crying is allowed but it occurs to me that some revisions may be needed to make allowances for bone breakages and severe loss of blood.

Scientists have proven that tear ducts are smaller in males than in females making it more difficult for boys/men to produce tears. Also, prolactin, a hormone used to stimulate milk production, is also used to make tears and women typically have about twice as much prolactin in their systems as men.  And while research may have provided some biological insight as to why we use more Kleenex than the "pee-standing-upus" species, it still doesn't explain why my kid, who suffered a pinky fracture, had to pull a John Wayne.

I want my son to be able to express the full gamut of his emotional experiences in healthy ways; punching a hole in drywall, numbing himself with illegal substances or becoming a cyborg are all unacceptable. Nor do I want him given to bouts of uncontrollable weeping at the sight of a drooping daisy. But crying should not mean he is weak or soft. It certainly doesn't mean that for girls and gender equality should run both ways. If we want to see our daughters free from barriers which inhibit their growth and development, we should want the same for our sons.

How do you feel about boys being able to cry? Share your thoughts in a comment.

 

Leave a Comment

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
  • anonymous on 01/12/2012

    I think this dirty turban wearer was crying when I was peeing on his face

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GIHKP3EX2zw

  • anonymous on 01/19/2012

    First of all, from what you said, your son never actually cried :P All he did was a perhaps overdramatic, "Ow!!" (depending on his age I guess). Regardless, socially, for his own sake, he probably shouldn't cry publicly. However, I actually advise against actively telling your son not to cry, as all that will do is humiliate him, and teach him the wrong attitude. There's nothing wrong with a man crying when appropriate. Depending on his age, he may just be going through a melodramatic stage. When I was 10, I used to be a bit overdramatic, I'd cry at my own woes ("No video games because I did poorly on a test! SO UNFAIR" ;) , but I grew out of it pretty quickly. And that's just it, most kids don't need to be expressly taught when it it appropriate to cry, they learn from observance. My parents never actually told me it was bad to cry, I simply realized my friends didn't do it, and eventually stopped. It's just part of growing up.

  • anonymous on 01/24/2012

    Learning how to cry, for men, can be a powerful and enlightening experience. Lets face it, us women LOVE a man who can actually be man enough to show a sensitive time from time to time...

    Additionally, it is a POWERFUL stress reliever, which I strongly believe men need just as badly as women. Bottling up emotions until they rip apart into an "aggressive" display, just isn't healthy, and could actually lead to problems later on.

    Personally, I think an open discussion with some "real men" that explains that, yes, crying in public is probably not the best thing to do if you can help it, BUT, a good cry in private, is perfectly acceptable, and honestly, even desirable. Heck, schedule a "sad movie" night a couple times a month, where you openly EXPECT him to cry, if only to ensure he gets the emotional benefit that the occasional cry gives, as well as giving him a time and place where he can feel safe from the societal pressures to "not cry."

    Lets bring this "manly man" bullcrap to a close, within our generation!

Recently Asked Questions
0 Answers
0 Answers

More from iVillage

Our Experts

  • Jenny Isenman
    Jenny Isenman, AKA Jenny from the Blog, is a humor writer/wiper of tushies, noses, and countertops...
  • Becca Ludlum
    Becca Ludlum was born and raised in upstate New York and currently lives in Arizona with her sons...
  • Melissa Chapman
    Melissa Chapman blogs about her marriage and everything in between at marriedmysugardaddy.com, and...